Teach Students to Leave the First Tab

Teach Students to Leave the First Tab

A student finds a confident-sounding post about a health or science claim and brings it to class. The page has a sharp headline and a familiar-looking logo, but neither tells you who produced it or whether other sources support it. Instead of judging the page by its appearance, make the next step part of the lesson: leave the tab.

Investigate beyond the page

Stanford’s Civic Online Reasoning resources teach students to investigate sources, check what other sources say, and trace claims back to their original context. These are instructional strategies for evaluating online information; they do not mean that every claim can be settled with a quick search. A useful starting question is, “Who is behind this, and what can we find out about them elsewhere?”

Model the move on a projector using a claim suitable for the class. Open a new tab to look for independent information about the publisher, then search for coverage from sources with relevant expertise. If several pages repeat the same wording, ask whether they provide independent confirmation or point back to one original source.

Separate claim from evidence

Have students record three things: the claim, the evidence the page provides, and what they still do not know. That last column matters. A missing source or unanswered question is a reason to pause, not an invitation to fill the gap with a guess.

A practical classroom routine is to pause before sharing, investigate the source elsewhere, and compare the claim with credible independent information. Students can then explain what the sources establish and what remains uncertain. The aim is not to make every learner a specialist; it is to make “I need to check” a defensible response.